Ohio Insurer Report Card
Loading the latest report…
How do Ohio property insurance companies treat their own policyholders after a loss? We graded them using our claim files: how long they took to pay, how far their offers fell short of what was finally paid, and how often the dispute had to go to appraisal.
How the grades work
- Offer shortfall: how far the insurance company's offer was below the amount finally paid (by settlement or appraisal award). 40% means policyholders would have been paid 40% less by accepting the offer.
- Days to pay: average days from when we took the claim to the first insurance payment.
- Appraisal: the share of claims where the disagreement went to appraisal.
- Grade: based on the offer shortfall (A: 10% or less, B: up to 20%, C: up to 35%, D: up to 50%, F: more), one grade lower for paying slower than 90 days or for needing appraisal on half the claims or more.
Only insurance companies with at least 5 of our Ohio claims in the year are listed. No policyholder, claim or dollar details are published. Results describe the claims we handled, which are often the ones where the policyholder already felt underpaid, and may not reflect every claim an insurer handles.
Think your insurance company is underpaying you?
Get a free policy review from a licensed Ohio public adjuster.
Get started